Replacement officials

The first quarter of Monday night's Atlanta-Denver game was perhaps the longest 60 minutes in NFL history, and not because Peyton Manning threw three interceptions.

The mistakes and hesitations by the replacement officials were far worse as fights broke out during the chaotic six-minute delay the refs needed to sort out a fumble recovery.

Three calls were overturned in the first half and players and coaches complained bitterly that illegal contact downfield was overlooked if not outrightly ignored by the officiating crew.

Here's a sampling of the critiques and calls for the NFL to settle immediately with the regular officials, before the league suffers irreparable harm:
From Denver Post columnist Mark Kiszla:


Hey, NFL commissioner Roger Goodell. We beg you to stop this madness before there's a riot on the field among angry, 300-pound men in helmets.
Kiss and make up with the real game officials.
Life is too short for bad football. And the NFL is too dangerous to be policed by officials without a clue.
Never thought I'd say it, but: Gosh, do I miss Ed Hochuli.
In the name of integrity, you've got to stop the madness, Mr. Goodell.

From Michael David Smith, at Pro Football Talk:

Players came off the bench to get into the scrum. Coaches came off the sideline to get involved. Players were getting in officials’ faces and yelling at them, and in some cases putting their hands on the officials. The officials seemed totally overwhelmed and unsure how to restore order.

In the end, only one player (Falcons defensive end Ray Edwards, whom the referee referred to as “93 red”) was penalized, and no one was ejected. It’s a mystery why other players weren’t penalized. In particular, why wasn’t Broncos center J.D. Walton ejected for grabbing an official and pulling him away from the pile?

From Redskins linebacker Chris Wilson, expressing concern to USA Today after Sunday's chippy game against St. Louis nearly deteriorate into a brawl:

"I think the frustration has grown. If it escalates, you're talking about fistfights."

But the NFL hasn't shown any sign of recognizing it has a problem. In an e-mail to USA Today, NFL spokesman Greg Aiello wrote: "Officiating is never perfect. The current officials have made great strides and are performing admirably under unprecedented scrutiny and great pressure.

Comments

10
Want to be heard? Login or Sign Up to join the Conversation!

Marq Cerqua This whole scenario must be embarrassing for the NFL. I'm also sure it was avoidable.

8 mons ago

Central McClellion The stage is a big one! It's a first time for everything. Let go Replacement Ref's

8 mons ago

Jitter Fields There is nothing wrong with the officials and how they are officiating the game. They are being pick on because they are called replacements. It is the name given to them that's causing a little stir. Whenever the other officials comeback, if they comeback, the way the game was being officiated you might not notice a difference. However, I think current officials will get tougher on all the monkey business dished out by players and coaches. They are doing pretty good right now!

8 mons ago

Courtney Brown Replacement officials need to be replaced.

8 mons ago

Chris Jones These are rookie refs on a pro level lets come to some sort of an agreement and get the experience back out there making calls. You can tell that their rookies too. Missing calls!

8 mons ago

Orson Mobley Sometimes it is better to do the right thing, than being right, the game is suffering

8 mons ago

Gene Lang NFL pay the refs and get them back on the field. Its not necessary to always play hardball!!!

8 mons ago

Tony Coats Player safety is obviously important. If he went to great lengths to penalize the Saints for Bountygate he needs to get the officiating problem under control before it spins further out of control.

8 mons ago

Jorge Diaz I am with Steve Young , if the NFL cares about player safety how could they continue to let theses officals be out there ! They need fix this and get the trained officals back in the game !!

8 mons ago

Gary Scamehorn NFL needs to get this right.Fix it!

8 mons ago