WHO ARE THE NFL'S MOST POPULAR PLAYERS?

By TOM WEIR

SOTL.com

Two interesting polls about the popularity of NFL players -- or lack thereof -- have surfaced this week.

Let's look at "most popular" first. You'd think it would be a quarterback, but then again a guy like Tom Brady loses votes in the New York market every time he humbles the Jets. Likewise, Aaron Rodgers is probably a hard sell in Chicago.

Quarterbacks did score high in a poll of the general public arranged by Forbes magazine, but it turns out the most popular player is the guy who does the shampoo commercials -- Pittsburgh's Troy Polamalu.

He scored a 63% popularity rating, which is rather outstanding for a defensive back who has wreaked havoc on so many teams.

Next up: Drew Brees, 62%; Peyton Manning, 59%; Aaron Rodgers and Rob Gronkowski, 58%, Robert Griffin III and Donald Driver, 57%, and Matthew Stafford, 56%.

No Tim Tebow? Anyone surprised about that?

But the name of the Jets quarterback does arise in another poll.

SI.com also has a poll out this week, on who's the NFL's most overrated player. That poll solicited answers from only NFL players, and Tebow was the overwhelming top choice:

Tim Tebow, 34%

Mark Sanchez, 8%

Tony Romo, 8%

Michael Vick, 4%

Ray Lewis, 3%

Do you agree or disagree with these polls? Who's getting left out, and who should be included? Gve us an opinion in the comments section.

Comments

11
Want to be heard? Login or Sign Up to join the Conversation!

Brandon Williams That hair was a great investment for #43...

7 mons ago

Adrian Peterson Hard to say (Tebow) most overrated considering his not a starter>>

7 mons ago

Jeff Nixon Mario Williams (Buffalo Bills) was left out of the most overrated.

7 mons ago

Andrew Provence Yeah, I can see the connection with endorsements ... the players I've seen the most on commercials aren't on the list .... Cam Newton, Eli Manning and (former player) Deion Sanders

7 mons ago

Chris Jones Tebow definitely rank #1

7 mons ago

Earl Thomas Tim Tebow is a trick pony player. Tebow should have gone to Jacksonville where he is a star.The New York media when they get through with this guy, no team but Jacksonville will touch himI think he is the most hyped non playing player in the last 20 years.

7 mons ago

Earl Thomas The most popular players will always be the QB's because thats where it starts and ends.It does not have have to be the team with the winning record, but the guy must have stats.So here we go.1 Aaron Rogers, 2. Tom Brady, 3. Matt Schab 4. Tony Romo and 5. Drew Brees are the best.The most popular is Rogers,Manning,Manning and Tebow.

7 mons ago

Stacey Hairston Overrated list looks pretty good at the top and slowly gets ridiculous as it gets to the bottom. Ray Lewis overrated?? That is just laughable. Only someone who has never played a down of football in their entire life would say he is overrated. On the downside of his career maybe, but never overrated. Michael Vick overrated? Please, whoever you are that mentions him as overrated. You hating him does make him overrated.

7 mons ago

Courtney Brown Tebow is definitely #1 on this list. I agree that Ray Lewis shouldn't be anywhere near this list. How the hell do you put a future Hall of Famer on this list?

7 mons ago

R. St. Clair Tim Tebow is overrated and Mike Vick and Ray Lewis shouldn't be on the list.

7 mons ago